Jennifer Lopez received praise from Watch What Happens Live host Andy Cohen for never having pleaded the Fifth during her first two turns playing the truth-telling game on his show. The praise lingered for about two minutes after Cohen asked Lopez to play “Shag, Marry, Kill.” The game goes like this: Cohen names three people and Lopez must choose one to marry, one to shag, and one to kill. “I have to kill one of them?” the glamorous Lopez asked. Cohen tossed JLo her American Idol workmates for her choices: Keith Urban, Harry Connick Jr. and Ryan Seacrest.
JLo had already selected Seacrest for marriage when she bailed and pleaded the Fifth for the first time in three appearances. Apparently choosing to kill Harry Connick, Jr. or Keith Urban — even in a game — was too much for the kind-hearted JLo. She took the next question without hesitation: she hates Ben Affleck‘s phoenix back tattoo. It’s “awful,” JLo added. Cohen is getting soft! That’s too easy a question.