Entertainment, TV, Celebrity, Culture

Follow @2Paragraphs
  • Daily Edition
    • Barack_ObamaBarack Obama Warns Not To Separate Black History, “We’re The Enslaved People”
    • Bernie SandersBernie Sanders Says This “Greedy” Enemy Unites Even Divided Americans
    • Barack_ObamaBarack Obama Links To Tyre Nichols $1 Million Fund, Speaks Out On Tragedy
  • Business
    • Elon_MuskMusk, Tesla Passed Over As Netflix EV of Choice, GM Steps Up Streamer Profile
    • Ph.D. student Omar Samara of UC Davis with an agrivoltaic farmAgrivoltaic Farming Trend Surges, Success Stories Around The Globe
    • Dwayne_Johnson by Eva Rinaldi [CC BY-SA 2.0], via Wikimedia CommonsDwayne Johnson Knocks On His Wooden Head After $100 Million Annual Sales
  • Culture
    • Elizabeth banksElizabeth Banks Jumps Off Cliff in Strapless Bikini, ‘Cocaine Bear’ Exclusive BTS
    • Madelyn Cline, Outer Banks, photo: Curtis Baker/NetflixMadelyn Cline Poses Topless In Sheer Hosiery, “Undeniable Force of Nature”
    • Serena Williams 2020 US OpenSerena Williams Finally Speaks On Will Smith: “I’ve Been There”
  • Sports
    • JJ Watt by Jeffrey Beall [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia CommonsJJ Watt Trolls Tom Brady On NFL Retirement, How To Spend His Money
    • Kyrie_IrvingKyrie Irving Says He Still Believes, But “We Can’t Just Be One Of Those Teams”
    • Tom_BradyTom Brady Plans To Torment Haters By Never Going Away
  • Food
    • Jennifer GarnerJennifer Garner Reveals Her Favorite ‘Dry January’ Treat at Home
    • Dark ChocolateAre Dark Chocolate Fears Overblown? Cadmium, California, and “Ouch, Ouch” Disease
    • Wendy's restaurantWendy’s New Riddle Stumps Social Media — “Chili in Philly?”
  • Interviews
    • Cranberries_in_a_bucketDo Cranberries Really Help UTI? A Doctor Answers With New Evidence
    • Lauren Lovett The Speech Ring InventorVideo: The Speech Ring Inventor on Overcoming Fear of Public Speaking
    • Surge first out gay superhero in the moviesFirst Out Gay Movie Superhero Surge Speaks on Humor, Responsibility
  • Cool Stuff
    • Ice-T on LAW & ORDER: SVU (Virginia Sherwood/NBC)Ice-T’s Wife Flaunts Brand New Range Rover With Front Seat Refrigerator
    • Bergdorf Goodman 5th Avenue store in NYCChristian Louboutin Reveals 3.5″ Spring Mules With ‘Vibrant Red’ Nail Polish
    • Cardi_BCardi B Says She Hit Jackpot With $30,000 Chanel Slot Machine Bag
  • People
    • Bradley_Cooper,Bradley Cooper’s Net Worth Wealth Soars, $100 Million Plus
    • Barbara CorcoranWho Is Barbara Corcoran’s FBI Agent, Football Star Husband?
    • Israel Del ToroWatch ESPYS Pat Tillman Recipient MSgt. Del Toro Talk About Resilience
  • Contact

Psychiatrist’s Duty to Warn in Cases of Patients Posing Threats

by Michael J. Racette in Law | August 9, 2012

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • More
  • Linkedin
  • Reddit
  • Email

Following the recent shootings at a Colorado movie theater, various media outlets have reported that shortly before the shootings, the suspect’s treating psychiatrist had taken steps to warn officials at the university where the suspect was enrolled that he might be dangerous.  When is a psychiatrist—one who is hired to provide confidential mental health counseling—obligated to breach the duty of confidentiality owed to a patient and warn or take other steps to protect others?  Forty years ago, the answer–in every state–was: “never.”  Now, the answer is: “It depends.”  In 1976, California Supreme Court issued a seminal decision holding that when a therapist determines (or should determine, by the profession’s standards), that a patient “presents a serious danger of violence to another,” the therapist owes a duty to the intended victim to take reasonable steps to protect that potential victim.  Since that decision, most states have—through case law or by specific legislation—imposed a similar measure of duty.

This places the treating psychiatrist in a difficult position, because it may not be clear at the time of treatment how serious the patient is about causing harm, or even on whom that harm might befall.  “I have a gun and I’m going to kill Mr. So-and-So tonight, because he is sleeping with my wife” is different than, “I think people who go to movie theaters don’t deserve to live.”  Are psychiatrists reliably capable of predicting who poses a real threat to cause harm to others?  And if there is reason for sufficient concern, what steps would be reasonable to take? Tell a specific individual of a threat? Inform the police? Take steps to involuntarily commit the patient to a locked psychiatric facility?  The answers to these and other related questions usually seem (rightly or wrongly) much clearer after an event than during treatment, when the psychiatrist must determine whether something rises to the level requiring him or her to breach the very delicate relationship of trust necessary for successful treatment of a patient.  Hindsight is 20-20.  In our desire to place blame (and also thereby possibly provide financial compensation to innocent victims) we should not ignore the important and difficult service that mental health counselors provide to countless individuals and to society as a whole.  // Michael Racette

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • More
  • Linkedin
  • Reddit
  • Email

Is the Jury Still Out on Trial by Jury?

Alexis de Tocqueville

Load More

  • Recent
  • Trending
  • Popular
  • Waiters Get Back $500K Tips From Greedy NYC Restaurant
  • Supreme Court Saves SCOTUScare, Scalia Regrets
  • Justice Clarence Thomas Sides With Liberals On Free Speech
  • Uber Just Unwillingly Hired All Its California Drivers
  • Supreme Court Lets Eminem Style Off The Hook
2paragraphs on APPLE NEWS | 2paragraphs Amazon Shop | SEE MORE 2paragraphs ARTICLES
  • About 2paragraphs
  • Privacy
  • Terms of Use
  • Dedication
  • Map
  • Fresh
  • Law
  • How-To
  • Personal
  • Books

© 2012-2023, 2paragraphs Productions, LLC

  • Buffer
  • Diggit
  • Email
  • More
  • Facebook
  • Flattr
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Pinterest
  • Print
  • Reddit
  • Stumble
  • tumblr
  • Twitter
  • VK
  • WhatsApp
  • Yummly
  • Xing