Entertainment, TV, Celebrity, Culture

Follow @2Paragraphs
  • Daily Edition
    • Hillary Clinton by Gage Skidmore [CC BY-SA]Hillary Clinton Says Real ‘Pro-Life’ Advocates Need These 5 Things
    • Rep. Lauren BoebertLauren Boebert Slams Joe Biden Blooper, “We Like Babies”
    • Ted CruzTed Cruz Stuns Liberals With Savage TikTok Interrogation, “Go Ted!”
  • Business
    • Sen. Elizabeth WarrenSen. Elizabeth Warren Laughs at Bank CEOs Doing Their Own Stress Tests
    • Randi ZuckerbergRandi Zuckerberg Sarcastically Mocks Crypto Boys Club
    • Daymond JohnDaymond John Drops Elon Musk Icebreaker on Twitter, ‘Money v. Meeting’
  • Culture
    • Lili ReinhartLili Reinhart Strikes Sexy Pose in Satin Bra, ‘Marilyn Monroe 2.0’
    • Danica PatrickDanica Patrick Flaunts Legs in High-Tide Shorts, ‘Swiftie for Life’
    • Ana de ArmasAna de Armas’s ‘Blonde’ Oscars Lipstick Is For Sale
  • Sports
    • Naomi Osaka, US Open 2020Naomi Osaka Flaunts Bare Belly in Crop Top, Reveals Victoria’s Secret Collab
    • Gov Greg AbbottTexas Gov. Greg Abbott Picks Alabama Over Houston, Fails Politics 101
    • Michael_Jordan_and_Barack_ObamaBarack Obama Knocks Out #1 Seed Purdue In NCAA Round 2, ‘A Crime’
  • Food
    • Jennifer GarnerJennifer Garner Reveals Her Favorite ‘Dry January’ Treat at Home
    • Dark ChocolateAre Dark Chocolate Fears Overblown? Cadmium, California, and “Ouch, Ouch” Disease
    • Wendy's restaurantWendy’s New Riddle Stumps Social Media — “Chili in Philly?”
  • Interviews
    • Cranberries_in_a_bucketDo Cranberries Really Help UTI? A Doctor Answers With New Evidence
    • Lauren Lovett The Speech Ring InventorVideo: The Speech Ring Inventor on Overcoming Fear of Public Speaking
    • Surge first out gay superhero in the moviesFirst Out Gay Movie Superhero Surge Speaks on Humor, Responsibility
  • Cool Stuff
    • Ice-T on LAW & ORDER: SVU (Virginia Sherwood/NBC)Ice-T’s Wife Flaunts Brand New Range Rover With Front Seat Refrigerator
    • Bergdorf Goodman 5th Avenue store in NYCChristian Louboutin Reveals 3.5″ Spring Mules With ‘Vibrant Red’ Nail Polish
    • Cardi_BCardi B Says She Hit Jackpot With $30,000 Chanel Slot Machine Bag
  • Contact
  • Privacy

Rights Watch: Tweeter’s IP, Words and Whereabouts Turned Over to Government

by Michael J. Racette in Law | September 17, 2012

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • More
  • Linkedin
  • Reddit
  • Email

Can the state compel Twitter to produce a criminal defendant’s once (but no longer) public Twitter postings and Twitter log-in information (routinely collected and known only to Twitter) to bolster its case against a defendant?  If so, does that defendant have any right to oppose those efforts? Manhattan Supreme Court Judge Matthew Sciarrino, Jr., in a series of court rulings in the prosecution of Occupy Wall Street protester Malcolm Harris, says Twitter must surrender the tweets and Harris must sit on his once busy hands. Mr. Harris was arrested and charged with disorderly conduct in connection with Occupy Wall Street protests that temporarily blocked the Brooklyn Bridge in October 2011.  Mr. Harris claims that the “protesters were led…onto the bridge by police and had a reasonable belief that their conduct was authorized.”  Hunting for a contradiction, prosecutors requested a subpoena compelling Twitter to provide all of Mr. Harris’ “tweets” between September 15 and December 30, 2012–even seeking the IP addresses, locations, and dates from which Mr. Harris logged in to Twitter. Such information had never been publicly available.

Judge Sciarrino then denied Mr. Harris’ motion to quash the subpoena, and Twitter’s later similar motion to quash, ruling that Mr. Harris had no proprietary interest in his Twitter account information, and therefore had no legal standing to weigh in on the matter, and ruling that because Mr. Harris had revealed the information to third parties (the public in the case of his postings, and Twitter, in the case of his log in data), he had no reasonable expectation of privacy in any of that information. Joining the fight, the ACLU argued that Mr. Harris should be able to formally oppose the subpoena because it implicates his free speech and privacy rights under the First and Fourth Amendments. It argued that the subpoena calling for the production of detailed information about Mr. Harris’ whereabouts over a three-month period, would have a “chilling effect” on his and countless others’ Internet communications, and that he did have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the log-in data because giving that data to Twitter was not truly “voluntary” in any meaningful way. Not persuaded, Judge Sciarrino ordered Twitter to produce the records. Safe to say most people will be surprised to learn that they have no procedural right to challenge a government subpoena calling for information about their words, their whereabouts and their activities.  // Michael Racette

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • More
  • Linkedin
  • Reddit
  • Email

Can Rachel Sue Nick After “the Most Shocking Bachelor Pad Finale” Ever?

So Sue Me (ABC-TV)

Load More

  • Recent
  • Trending
  • Popular
  • Waiters Get Back $500K Tips From Greedy NYC Restaurant
  • Supreme Court Saves SCOTUScare, Scalia Regrets
  • Justice Clarence Thomas Sides With Liberals On Free Speech
  • Uber Just Unwillingly Hired All Its California Drivers
  • Supreme Court Lets Eminem Style Off The Hook
2paragraphs on APPLE NEWS | 2paragraphs Amazon Shop | SEE MORE 2paragraphs ARTICLES
  • About 2paragraphs
  • Privacy
  • Terms of Use
  • Dedication
  • Map
  • Fresh
  • Law
  • How-To
  • Personal
  • Books

© 2012-2023, 2paragraphs Productions, LLC

  • Buffer
  • Diggit
  • Email
  • More
  • Facebook
  • Flattr
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Pinterest
  • Print
  • Reddit
  • Stumble
  • tumblr
  • Twitter
  • VK
  • WhatsApp
  • Yummly
  • Xing