In the Brooklyn Nine-Nine episode ‘The Audit’, the good news is that crime in Brooklyn is lower. The bad news is that means one of the borough’s precincts will shut down permanently. Each precinct is evaluated, and there’s no reason why the 99 shouldn’t receive a fair evaluation – that is, until they meet the auditor who turns out to be Detective Amy Santiago’s (Melissa Fumero) ex-boyfriend Teddy Wells. Last time we saw Teddy was in 2014, when Amy broke up with him. (Check out video below.)
Amy’s ex is portrayed by Kyle Bornheimer. He’s known for his roles on Casual (Jack Briggs), Angel from Hell (Brad), Agent Carter (Ray Krzeminski), Family Tools (Jack Shea), and Worst Week (Sam Briggs), among others. Bornheimer is also recognized for his roles in the films She’s Out of My League (Dylan), You Again (Tim), and Bachelorette (Joe). Brooklyn Nine-Nine airs Tuesdays at 8pm on FOX.