On the Return to Amish episode “Judgment Day,” while Mary tries to get a new start and Kate continues to slay as a fashion model/designer in New York City, Sabrina has an emotional reunion with Abe and Rebecca. Since the last season, after giving birth to her daughter, Sabrina became addicted to prescription pills, was living in her car, and then went into rehab. She worked hard to get herself turned around. Now she’s trying to regain custody of her daughter.
When Sabrina sees Abe, he tells her that it was painful to watch her fall. Sabrina wants to know why she’s learning this now — why didn’t he say something then? She asks him “Why am I finding out that it was a huge ass issue now, why didn’t you…” Abe interrupts her to say he didn’t know how. “How do you go about telling someone something like that without hurting or even worse?” he explains. When Sabrina tells him about hard it was to turn things around – rehab, working 80 hours a week, therapy and counseling, she says, “Now you’re acting like it wasn’t worth any of it.” Abe throws the dagger, “What did you do after rehab?” Sabrina admits she had a relapse. Return to Amish airs Sundays at 9pm on TLC.