Jeremiah Raber of Return to Amish thinks Kate, who left the Amish world to become a model and designer, is selling her soul in New York City. He also believes that every job she gets is being handed to her, as if she’s not working hard for her success. According to Kate, Jeremiah believes Kate is in the Illuminati – you know, the secretive group that’s behind all the famous actors and musicians. Jeremiah hasn’t denied it. He doesn’t talk about the Illuminati in public anymore because, according to Kate, “He thinks they’re going to kill him.”
Jeremiah attests to the fact that he has received death threats through email and telephone calls. Return to Amish airs Sundays at 9pm on TLC.