On Return to Amish, when Katie-Ann visits ex-Amish Kate in New York City, Katie-Ann gets a head-to-toe makeover. And Katie-Ann likes it. Living in the English world feels good, she says. And then when she gets to go to a rodeo, watch out. Katie-Ann knows how to flirt!
At the rodeo, Katie-Ann meets “one of the cutest guys she ever met,” (which isn’t a lot, but anyway). After shaking hands, Katie-Ann doesn’t hesitate to ask him, “Are you single?” He said he’s not, and that’s probably a good thing. Katie-Ann is going to have to ease into this new lifestyle if or when she actually leaves the Amish world behind. Return to Amish airs Sundays at 9pm on TLC.