On Return to Amish, Kate was able to break from her Amish upbringing and is now making it in New York City as a model. When she gets a visit from young Katie-Ann, watch out. Katie -Ann gets a makeover – she cuts her hair, wears makeup, and a form-fitting red dress.
Katie-Ann says she’s “tired of being this plain old Amish girl.” The only reason why she would stay Amish is for her friends and family. But, as she says, “I know I won’t be happy. So I know it’s not worth staying Amish.” How quickly will she leave? And how will Mary take it? Return To Amish airs Sundays at 9pm on TLC.